Gone Girl Telegraph review

Gone Girl, review: 'shocking'

David Fincher's adaptation of Gillian Flynn's best-seller, which stars Ben Affleck and Rosamund Pike, is unnerving and provoking, says Robbie Collin

473

270

0

3

746

Email

By Robbie Collin

11:01AM BST 19 Oct 2014

14 Comments

Directed by David Fincher. Starring: Rosamund Pike, Ben Affleck, Carrie Coon, Kim Dickens, Neil Patrick Harris, Tyler Perry, Missi Pyle, Casey Wilson, Emily Ratajkowski.

Cert 18, 145 mins.

Can someone vanish if, in the first place, they were never truly there? A missing-person thriller might not seem like a likely forum for this kind of metaphysical grappling, but David Fincher, the director of The Social Network, Fight Club and Zodiac, is not a filmmaker prone to swaddling his audience in the consolations of the likely.

Fincher’s 10th film, Gone Girl, is based closely on Gillian Flynn’s best-selling 2012 novel which used a page-turning plot line – the sudden disappearance of a smart, pretty, married woman called Amy Elliott-Dunne (Rosamund Pike) – to unpick the modern mania for presenting a perfected version of ourselves to others, even as the truth roils and bubbles underneath.

In Fincher’s hands, that smart but arguably undisciplined story becomes something even wilder and yet perversely also more controlled – a neo-noir thriller turned on its blood-spattered head. Here, it’s the homme, rather than the femme, who has the fatale aura, and what comes out of the past only serves to further cloud the murky present.

Related Articles

• David Fincher: from Ewok killer to Gone Girl 

  02 Oct 2014

• Rosamund Pike: How my ex-addict lover (age 53) gave me new lease of life

  20 Sep 2014

• The 101 best films on Netflix 

  01 Jan 2015

• The best films in cinemas now 

  27 Dec 2014

But above all, it's a delicious exercise in audience-baiting: what begins as a he-said, she-said story of mounting, murderous suspense, lurches at its fulcrum into the kind of hot mess Brian De Palma might have cooked up 20 years ago in his attic. Reports that Flynn had, while writing the screenplay, dramatically reworked her original ending, are accurate, but only after a fashion. The plot is essentially unchanged, but every screw has been tightened, and a new confrontation scene delivers a brutal, yet agonisingly un-final, showdown.

The film begins cryptically, close to that end-point, before looping back to the morning of Amy’s disappearance from the home she shares with her husband Nick, brilliantly played by Ben Affleck as a man who has finally realised his life will never quite live up to the promise of his jawline. This is recession-era America, old and tired, and even the dawn inching over the shuttered shops looks stale.

We learn that Nick and Amy lost their New York-based writing jobs in the downturn, now he and his twin sister Margot (Carrie Coon) run a bar in the town where he grew up, while she sits at home, gathering dust.

These scenes are stern and crisp, underscored not with music, but the dust-dry buzz of air-conditioning and fluorescent light. We hear it when Nick comes home to find the living room furniture turned upside down and his wife of five years nowhere to be seen – and again when he’s taken in for questioning by Detective Rhonda Boney (Kim Dickens), who wonders if there’s more to this man than meets her already sceptical eye.

Soon, though, via an entry in Amy’s diary, the film flashes back to the couple’s first meeting at a chichi New York party. The voluptuous, Angelo Badalamenti-ish score, by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, aches and swells, while Amy and Nick’s conversation snaps along to a seductive, screwball beat. Afterwards, they go walking arm in arm through the city at night, when they’re suddenly enveloped by clouds of icing sugar that come billowing out of a baker’s window. They stop and share a sweetened kiss in the tawny moonlight. The past, for these two, looks like a sugar storm.

The film shuttles between these two time periods, and Fincher’s masterstroke is in making neither ring entirely true: the director is so adept at crafting concretely plausible fictions, he knows exactly which details to tweak to throw the balance slightly off.

In the present, Amy is nowhere to be seen. In the past, she’s everywhere. Pike, who’s so often quietly admirable in films of varying quality, has waited more than a decade for a role this juicy, but what amazes you is how methodically she seizes on it: not with the hungry pounce and rip of a wild cat, but the rhythmic constrictions of an anaconda. Amy is the best thing Pike has ever done: her performance is taut and poised, and at times almost masque-like. While her diary voiceovers swoon with emotion, her face gives you almost nothing.

It’s possible that Amy’s darker monologues may induce in female viewers the same double squirm felt by men listening to Edward Norton’s Fight Club voiceover: the shock that someone would ever dare to say such things out loud, coupled with a pit-of-the-stomach throb of recognition. There is a key speech in the novel in which Amy describes the fate of the "cool girl" – the archetypal sexy girlfriend who morphs, unbidden, into a pliant wife — that Pike delivers with a note of venomous triumph that makes you want to cheer.

The revealing of Amy’s fate, which takes place not at the end of the film but at its centre, with a mad magician’s flourish, is expertly handled, re-energising the plot while ushering in some fun new characters, not least of all Neil Patrick Harris as Amy’s WASP-y ex-lover and Tyler Perry as a grandstanding lawyer. And for all its simmering malice and buried secrets, it’s worth remembering that this is David Fincher in fun mode: unnerving, shocking and provoking for better and for worse, in sickness and in health, but mostly sickness.